Part 3: How to Write and Manage an RFP: A Strategic Guide for AI Services

A Story of Missed Opportunities

Imagine this…. a major retail company, excited about embracing AI, releases a Request for Proposal (RFP) for a new predictive analytics platform. The stakes are high, this platform is expected to transform inventory decisions, optimize supply chains, and forecast demand in unprecedented ways. They release an incredibly detailed RFP, specifying everything from particular technologies to the types of algorithms they think they need. They receive bids, choose a vendor, and the project kicks off.

However, as development progresses, it becomes painfully obvious that the RFP’s scope and goals were too rigid. The company overlooked critical factors like integration with existing systems, scalability for future expansion, and alignment with broader business strategies. The project stalls, budgets run over, and frustration rises. What started as a promising AI initiative turns into a cautionary tale of how even the most well-intentioned RFPs can fall short if strategy and execution aren’t properly aligned.

Pain Point: The Traditional Software Development RFP Process won’t work for AI Projects

If you’re a CTO, CDO, or Chief Innovation Officer, this scenario might sound and feel familiar. AI projects differ greatly from traditional IT or software design and implementations. They involve more complexity, require alignment across multiple departments, and often include rapidly evolving technologies. Yet, many companies approach AI RFPs as if they’re routine IT or software exercises. They fill them with technical specifications but miss a key point, which is a clear focus on business outcomes.

Traditional RFP processes can create significant bottlenecks. By over-specifying technical details or failing to align with the business strategically, companies often end up with proposals that:

1. Are too rigid: This approach stifles innovation by mandating specific technologies or methodologies rather than focusing on business outcomes.
2. Are too vague: Lack of clarity about business goals results in misalignment between the vendor’s approach and the company’s vision.
3. Miss the context: They fail to account for the company’s AI maturity level or the vendor's ability to work with existing data and infrastructure.

The result? AI projects that struggle to deliver ROI, suffer from scope creep, or even worse, are abandoned midway through the project.

‍A Contrarian View: Forget the Laundry List, Focus on Strategy

Conventional wisdom suggests that the more details you provide in your RFP, you’ll receive better responses. However, a more effective approach is to focus on the desired business outcomes and allow room for innovation. Instead of specifying every technical requirement, define what success looks like (e.g., “a 20% reduction in operational costs through AI-powered predictive maintenance”). This opens the door for vendors to propose innovative, tailored solutions that fit your needs. By inviting strategic partners to solve your business challenges creatively, you move from dictating the process to exploring solutions you may not have anticipated.

The Blueprint: How to Write a Strategic RFP for AI Services

1. Define the Business Problem, Not Just the Technical Requirements. Start by clearly articulating the business challenge you want to address. For example, “We need a recommendation system to boost customer engagement and drive a 15% increase in sales within the next 12 months.” This focuses the RFP on outcomes rather than prescriptive technical solutions.
2. Include AI Maturity and Current State Assessments. Provide an overview of your current AI maturity. Do you have an established data infrastructure? Are cloud services already integrated? Are your teams familiar with AI concepts? This context helps vendors tailor their proposals, saving time and aligning expectations.
3. Invite Proposals That Prioritize Flexibility and Innovation. AI projects require flexibility and iterative development. Encourage vendors to present how they would adjust their approach based on evolving insights, ensuring they can pivot as your needs change.
4. Require a Roadmap with Milestones and Metrics. Insist on a detailed roadmap that aligns milestones with business outcomes, not just technical deliverables. This keeps the project focused on strategic goals and ensures progress is measured meaningfully.
5. Ask for Use Case Validation and ROI Projections. Request that vendors provide a high-level use case validation or proof-of-concept plan, including rough ROI projections to gauge the potential value they can offer. Vendors who clearly articulate the business impact of their solutions are more likely to deliver results.

‍

Managing the RFP Process: A 10-Step Guide to AI RFP Success

1. Align on Objectives and Define the Project Scope
   • Clearly define your project’s objectives and outcomes to establish alignment among all stakeholders from the C-suite to technical teams. This unified vision ensures that the vendor selection process focuses on firms that understand the complexity and scale of your AI initiatives. Misalignment here can lead to costly delays and poor outcomes, so setting a clear and cohesive scope at the right level of detail upfront is crucial.
2. Engage Stakeholders Early
   • Involve key stakeholders, including representatives from IT, data science, and business units, early in the process. Engaging these parties ensures the RFP addresses a comprehensive range of requirements including; technical, operational, and financial, while fostering internal support for the project.
3. Develop a Clear, Comprehensive RFP Document
   • A well-structured RFP document is crucial for attracting quality proposals. It should provide:some text
     • Introduction: An overview of your organization, the project’s strategic significance, and its alignment with broader business objectives.
     • Scope of Work: Define tasks, deliverables, and expected outcomes, emphasizing business challenges, the current state of your data, and any existing AI technologies, or other IT systems involved.
     • Evaluation Criteria: Outline the parameters for assessing proposals, including technical expertise, AI experience, innovation, scalability, etc.
     • Submission Requirements: Specify deadlines, formats, and points of contact.
     • Contract Terms: Detail legal and operational terms, particularly around data security, IP ownership, and service-level agreements (SLAs) if appropriate.
4. Targeted Distribution
   • Instead of casting a wide net, focus on engaging the right vendors through targeted outreach. Use established industry channels and consider contacting AI providers you’ve worked with before or those with proven expertise in your domain. This approach ensures you attract vendors who understand your needs and have a track record of delivering high-impact solutions. Focus on a range of different vendor sizes, including the big players and boutique firms as well. 
5. Host Pre-Proposal Meetings
   • For complex AI projects, consider hosting pre-proposal meetings or briefing sessions. These meetings allow vendors to ask questions and clarify expectations, leading to more accurate and tailored proposals. This reduces the risk of misunderstandings that could lead to big differences in understood scope, and pricing, and could potentially derail the project later.
6. Implement a Rigorous Evaluation Process
   • Assemble a cross-functional evaluation team that includes members from operations, finance, and AI experts. This ensures a balanced and comprehensive assessment of proposals, weighing technical soundness, cost, and strategic alignment. A structured scoring system based on evaluation criteria allows for an objective and data-driven decision-making process.
7. Vendor Selection and Negotiation
   • With a shortlist of vendors, move into detailed negotiations that focus not just on price but also on aligning expectations, timelines, and deliverables. Price is always important and must align with your available resources, but in this space you definitely get what you pay for. Pay attention to the vendor company culture, do they seem like a group of people you actually want to spend time with? Evaluate the vendor’s capacity for long-term support, flexibility, and innovation which is crucial for AI projects where adaptability is key. Clarity on issues such as data privacy, IP ownership, and scalability helps set a strong foundation for partnership.
8. Formalize the Agreement
   • Quickly formalize the agreement once negotiations are complete. The contract should clearly define outcomes, timelines, performance metrics, and contingency plans to reduce ambiguity and establish a solid foundation for collaboration.
9. Pilot, Then Scale
   • Before committing to a full-scale implementation, initiate a pilot or POC project. This mitigates risk, validates the vendor’s capabilities, and ensures that the solution delivers measurable business impact. Scaling up after a successful pilot allows for adjustments and refinements, increasing the likelihood of long-term success.
10. Continuous Project Monitoring and Performance Management
    • AI projects require ongoing management and collaboration. Establish regular check-ins, performance reviews, and monitoring mechanisms to track progress and ensure the project remains aligned with strategic objectives. Continuous evaluation allows for timely adjustments, ensuring the solution evolves with your business needs and technological advancements.

This guide provides a strategic, step-by-step approach to managing the RFP process effectively, maximizing the potential for your AI initiative to succeed.

Wrapping Up: The RFP Is Your Blueprint for AI Success

Creating an RFP for AI services isn’t about micromanaging every technical detail, it’s about defining business outcomes, encouraging creativity, and strategically managing the process. By rethinking RFPs as tools for innovation rather than bureaucratic hurdles, you lay a solid foundation for AI success.

The next time you draft an RFP, avoid over-specification. Focus on articulating a vision for AI success, and allow the best vendors to showcase their innovative solutions.